The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? . Heres a simple but effective planeswalker. When Stronghold Arena enters the battlefield, you gain 3 life for each time it was kicked. The challenge is to have enough demons on the battlefield for it to be better. Sometimes, one mana is worth much more than being able to play a card a turn earlier. What happens when I remove Mistbind Clique with its champion trigger still on the stack? Obviously you can build a decent mono or bi-color deck pretty cheaply, but many decks are tri-color, and getting all the fetches for that alone is backbreaking. Types: Creature Human Wizard. . My local meta runs alot of these pieces to limit alot of value engines (rhystic, fish, thrassios etc). Its a red and green card with a converted mana cost of 5. Dark Confidant was, for a long time, the hands-down winner of the most powerful Invitational card. Lightning Bolt, for example, does not count as a life loss card because it deals damage rather than causing a player to lose life. Which is weaker, Lightning Bolt or Force of Will? Here the basic curve again makes one play per turn, this time for six turns, whereas the "Confidant curve" goes 1/2/1+2/2+2/2+3/1+4 missing the sixth land drop just like the "basic curve". Even before that, the immediate value generated by Whisper has significant value. and our OT: Comparing Dark Confidant Dark Confidant, however, is no Wrenn and Six, and players would be mistaken to think that it is similar to Wrenn and Six. Dark Confidant gives you cards- a very important resource- at the cost of life- one of the least important. Artists proofs are CCG cards with blank white backs, printed by Wizards of the Coast and issued only to the artists. It's about mana efficiency and the curve, and in a Modern Jund list, Phyrexian Arena Stronghold Arena. Edition: Double Masters. Now, while Bob can come out on Turn 1, a Turn 2 Bob is probably more common so that's how I will be evaluating him for simplicity's sake. I'm starting to hate these budget threads (you can say it isn't a budget thread, but you'd only be lying to yourself). Now your cards are stepping all over each other rather than working as the well-oiled machine that more typifies Jund. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Lolth, Spider Queen has a good stabilizing effect, generating two tokens with reach and menace. to Liliana of the Veil Where as the modern deck will retain the same value for a good period of time and expect to sell at the same price you bought in to it with. Another staple in Cube and eternal formats, Reanimate is the cheapest way to put a creature from your graveyard onto the battlefield. From the rules: Specifically regarding CMC (emphasis mine): Example: Assault/Batterys mana cost is {3}{R}{G}. Oh, I'm well aware of its limitations. The "basic curve" makes one play per turn for the first five turns, totaling five plays while the "Confidant curve" makes a total of eight plays over the same amount of turns. Its hard to beat Kroxa when you keep casting it for its escape cost in drawn-out games. Please enable JavaScript to get the best experience from this site. Dark Confidant: At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. The Scarab God makes your opponents lose X life, where X is the number of zombies you control. He is a 2/1 body so if you lose 1 life, he can swing in for 2 to even things up. It's that important. Kicker and/or (You may pay an additional and/or as you cast this spell.) He alone is what makes some decks above average because of the attention he draws plus his card draw factor. If you don't answer bob he will make you regret the fact you didn't address his board presence. Dark Confidant {1} {B} Creature Human Wizard At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. Condition: . Something that has been mentioned but hasn't been explicitly stated is card typing. In pretty much every format ever Bob has been a staple card, and even in today's cEDH meta he's an autoinclude for Black decks. Pretty much what devonin said. Dark Confidant - MTG Cards | Cardmarket All Magic: The Gathering Cards Dark Confidant Dark Confidant 7 versions Show Versions Show Offers Product Availability No. Flip I think the downside is getting accentuated and the upside is more subtle than is easily understood. is better. 12 one-drops, 22 two-drops, 4 three-drops, 21 lands. What does Counterbalance counter, when revealing a split card? 708.4b The mana cost of a split card is the combined mana costs of its two halves. Here he returns with an uplifting house cut that deftly manipulates samples . Terms of Use | Bile Blight: Disease Targeting a Specific Creature Type. On my upkeep controlling a Dark Confidant I trigger revealing a card and losing life to it's cmc cost. RACING NOTES. For what Bob does, Liliana does nothing. Can I cast an instant or activate an ability between "whenever a creature dies" triggers, if the creatures die at the same time? Contact | In a mono-black deck, one that has some higher-CMC cards, I could very easily see Phyrexian Arena I have several black/x deck ideas for Modern where. Want one more Sanguine Bond in your EDH deck? Ages of men and of Outsiders have ascended and been forgotten, and only the bones of their cities and the And you do not have spend that much for a budget alternative. But you'll get an extra card and lose some life every turn if your Confidant lives, which is excellent against control and midrange strategies. , but I was thinking Blood Scrivener Blocks Tymna, too. you just drew for one life. Unless you get some other value out of them therefore (Hi Najeela) I'm even more skeptical of them than of Bob, since I think it likely that they draw you fewer cards overall. I like arena, but for a top deck you'd want bob probably. @wesdfgfgd Why not? Dark Confidant is a 2/1 Black Creature that lets you look at the top card of your library during your upkeep and put that card into your hand. I play B/G/R(Jund colors) in modern, my deck was around $300 to build. I understand it has a huge price tag but you can get a set for about 200 on eBay. It can be very interesting in some EDH decks as well with cheap cards since youll drain the table for a bunch. First turn: The Dark Confidant cannot affect our draw on the first turn so this is the usual minimum 9 one-drops to have drawn one and similar 9 lands, totaling 18 cards. Questions like this tend to be asked because the poster doesn't have quite the appreciation for just how important one mana is. Whatever the cost, as long as there isn't something you hate about Modern or something that you truly love about Standard, Modern is probably the best long-term deal. Drawing an extra card per turn should lead fairly directly to playing an extra card per turn, while simultaneously reducing the number of lands required to make each land drop. I was like "wtf this card sucks I lose life for it??" Thanks APPLE01DOJ and sylvannos, I'll see what I can do We can consider this closed, thanks to all who posted. Even with the recent MMA the hurdle between standard and modern is huge. According to the MTG comprehensive rules: When life totals are exchanged, each player gains or loses the amount of life necessary to equal the other players previous life total. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Dark Confidant - Modern Masters 2015 - NM - Black Mythic Human Wizard - MTG $32.00 $4.99 shipping or Best Offer SPONSORED *FOIL Dark Confidant - Ravnica - Graded BGS 8.5 $120.00 $17.77 shipping 2 watching SPONSORED MTG - Dark Confidant 081 Double Masters Mythic Creature Pack Fresh Near Mint NM $32.30 $5.60 shipping or Best Offer SPONSORED Feed the Swarm is like a more expensive but more flexible Vendetta. Articles and comments are user-submitted and do not represent official endorsements of this site. So yes, I believe you can easily have to skip a few years of standard just to fund a modern deck. Let's talk about this. TappedOut.js Blog Widget, SCORE: 9 | If you are running a deck that can reliably get combat damage through then I feel that. Phyrexian Arena is really the closest we have, and its pretty far from Dark Confidant's power level. I was surprised to see a card like [[Dark Confidant]] come back at such a hefty price for the ability that it has. You lose life equal to its mana value. No Bobs, no Goyfs, no LillysYou should find a deck that fits your play style, if that deck is jund then be prepared to shell out 1k. If you cast Assault, the resulting spell is a red spell with a converted mana cost of 1. Also, just read Barandis's answer about the curve. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Considering most of the decks were minimum 400 dollars at the time. He can swing in with two power per turn if you have free attacks or if you decide your life total needs to be protected. Example: Assault/Batterys mana cost is {3}{R}{G}. Another addition to Devonin's #5, Dark Confidant However, your opponent is down two cards for your troubles. @gufymike, Neither do I. Thats a lot of life to be lost. Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. That's 8 cards, not counting shocklands. In this case, I think it's worth much more than a quarter point of life per turn, too. Theres also the ward effect that gives you card advantage if your opponent targets it. Why are physically impossible and logically impossible concepts considered separate in terms of probability? If your intention is card advantage (which it is, when you're playing with Dark Confidant) in no way is Liliana of the Veil better. . Pain Seer and Blood Scrivener are creatures with similar effects. Flesh and Blood Digimon Funko Final Fantasy Greatness, at any cost. Gatherer is the Magic Card Database. You get card advantage, drain life, and your opponent loses something when the card enters the battlefield. Privacy statement | Dark Confidant Double Masters Change Version Add to Collection Create Price Alert Dark Confidant Show Card Oracle Text Tabletop Card Kingdom $ 19.99 eBay - Buy It Now $ 18.99 TCGplayer Mid $ 18.68 Magic Online Cardhoarder 0.91 tix MTGOTraders 0.91 tix Show Buylist Prices + Price History Tabletop MTGO 0 0.5 1 1.5 Oct 22 Nov 22 Dec 22 Jan 23 Feb 23 I think the only deck that plays Bob widely is probably Jund, there is still other black colour decks in Modern you can play such as Melira Pod, B/W Token, B/R burn etc. People are free to interpret it how they wish. Life loss cards in Magic are cards that have lose life or something similar in their text. blue red green multicolored Other 8 Cards (13%) 6 Cards (10%) 6 Cards (10%) . Neon Dynasty Featured a Hidden Praetor; Phyrexia: All Will Be One . You cast Mind Rot and knock two cards out of your opponent's hand. Thread locked. This site is unaffiliated. Well, partially it is because a simple 2-for-1 isn't particularly appealing - in a format with Ad Nauseum, Necropotence, Rhystic Study, Sylvan Library, etc, there isn't much need for a simple +1. Champion of Dusk can net you good card advantage in a vampire deck. Warlock Class sees play in Explorer as a way to add to your devotion, and as a mana sink. Note that you can draw more cards paying four different colors of mana if theres some kind of taxing effect online, like Thalia, Guardian of Thraben. Thank you very much. Note that this analysis is identical to the one which would occur for Howling Mine and several other cards. The stars gutter and the skies fade and the earth grows weary with years. Show All Versions. From the downside standpoint, I looked up a modern Jund deck, in fact the one that won the MTGO Modern Premier event this week. 10 COMMENTS | Probably one of the most hated cards thanks to its interaction with Witchs Oven, Cauldron Familiar drains your opponent for one life each time, and it partners with Mayhem Devil for extra damage in Explorer/Pioneer decks. It might only run a playset each of Marsh Flats , they both do the same thing but one is banned in legacy, and other isn't even played in modern. Ravnica: Dark Confidant Add To Wishlist Restock Notice Gatherer & Rulings NM EX VG G 4 available $17.84 Add to Cart Sell your Dark Confidant Switch to Foil Other Versions Show All Versions Customers who purchased Ravnica: Dark Confidant also bought. Connect with Us. Second turn: Again, the Confidant does not affect our draws so we still have the "basic curve" which tells us we want 8 two-drops and 15 lands, bringing our running total to 32 cards. 2023 Wizards. Why are trials on "Law & Order" in the New York Supreme Court? Dark Confidant BUDGET Alternatives do exist. Even when I'm losing I still enjoy drawing cards so there's that. Card Name: Dark Confidant Cost: 1B Color: Black Card Type: Creature - Human Wizard Power/Toughness: 2/1 Card Number: 74/229 Artist: Scott M. Fischer Card Text: At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. like i understand pod effects hitting creatures, but it's not like you're going to spend a spell to put bob in you hand so you can spend 2 mana and draw a card next turn. MTG- 1x NM Foil Dark Confidant - MM2 - Modern Masters 2015 - Black Creature Near Mint - never played, opened and straight into sleeve and binder Shipping: MTG Singles under $20 - These will ship via envelope unless you contact me and ask me not. I can't agree more. 27 Timeless Ultimate Guides and Tools for Magic the Gathering, Siege Rhino: A Portent of Defeat for your Enemies, Berserk MTG Card: Temporary but fatal power. Cards from expansions and special sets (like From the Vault, Commander, Duel Decks, etc) are legal in the Legacy format on the date of release of the expansion or . TappedOut.js Blog Widget. Dark Confidant was reprinted in Modern Masters. You want ninjas, evasive creatures, and cards that cost a lot and can be cast for alternative costs in this kind of deck so that your Yuriko triggers make your opponents lose a bunch of life. If that same hand contained Arena and Lili instead, you can't spend any mana on turn 2. If you can't afford the card, don't just replace it and expect the deck to work, cause it won't. This site works best with JavaScript enabled. Singles. Unless you're doing like no ban modern. Required fields are marked *. And those who aren't behind him quit being a noob! Zulaport Cutthroat: Avenge the Deaths of your Creatures! I think the biggest impediment to understanding here is making assumptions. as a direct replacement for Dark Confidant Then you have to decide which 3-drop to play on turn three, making the unenviable choice of delaying your draw engine and Lili by a turn each, or delaying your draw engine by two turns. It was the word "new" that threw me off. Delivered tomorrow*; Customer rating: 9.2 The literal and graphical information presented on this site This site 2023 TappedOut.net, LLC Dark tutleage and phyrexian arena. 2/1 Illustrated by Livia Prima Standard Not Legal Alchemy Not Legal Pioneer Not Legal Explorer Not Legal Modern Legal Brawl Not Legal Legacy Legal Historic It's all about the downside of Bob versus the upside. From there I thought it was worth looking at how much value we can expect from cards like Bob, Grob, and Mindblade.Speaking Grob and Mindblade, I did consider including them in the post, but decided against it because I didn't want to muddy the waters further. If you accept all cookies, we will transfer your data to our partners, who will aggregate this data with other website data about you. true considering they can most likley roll the standard deck they have in standard into modern. Shaman of the Pack has been making waves in Explorer as a good finisher in elfball decks since it was introduced to MTG Arena. Replacement For Dark Confidant. Singles. 9 one-drops, 8 two-drops, 8 three-drops, 11 four-drops, 24 lands. The players have influence over what turn the game ends and so an just over half end on turn 5, not accounting for pod composition. Its a red and green card with a converted mana cost of 5. The fact it says draw lets you keep up an advantage engine in that sense as well as having a good stat line and similar. He explained it perfectly. Saying DC is weaker than Liliana is almost impossible. February 8, 10. I can't picture a reason that I would want to inflict damage on myself just for an opportunity to draw an extra card (that I have to reveal). Any deck he is slapped in makes that deck 10 times better. It's appeal (imo) is because it isn't threatening enough to draw THAT much attention as it is cast or ETBs while still adding value. Its a staple in Legacy ANT (Ad Nauseam Tendrils) and EDH combo decks. Kroxa, Titan of Deaths Hunger is a good threat and win condition for Rakdos () decks in Explorer/Pioneer, and sometimes Modern. Board & Card Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who like playing board games, designing board games or modifying the rules of existing board games. Its especially interesting with cards like Sorin, Imperious Bloodlord that can cheat it into play. I made a decision to stop playing Standard as in the course of two seasons I'm likely to spend more putting decks together than I would with Modern anyway. Designs are printed using one of the highest quality photo printer. Deathrite Shaman unites ramp, graveyard hate, and a win condition all in the same 1-drop. Phyrexian Arena is the best option. $17.99) Condition: (Required) Near Mint. of Available Items 3054 No. You Do Your Best To Hide The Good Parts of Yourself EP by Laurence Guy, released 08 December 2022 1. I play in a similar meta, and can confirm that he is an all star if you can get the game to go longer than turn 5 (which honestly isn't that rare anymore now that Flash is gone). He holds swords when relevant. 1 Dark Confidant; 4 Tarmogoyf; 3 Seasoned Pyromancer; 3 Wrenn and Six; 1 Kroxa, Titan of Death's Hunger; . You lose life equal to its converted mana cost. Why? #3. Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. I was going under the assumption that someone would only focus on building a single T1 deck for a particular standard, so you saying you'd have to sell all of your decks to fund modern just helps my argument. @SocioMatt Blood Scrivener is the Dark Confidant. Then, you have other cards like Phyrexian Arena or Monastery Siege that do something very similar as Bob's effect. Why do small African island nations perform better than African continental nations, considering democracy and human development? does not, but the only one you even need is that it costs one less mana. It runs Dark Confidant and the average CMC is 1.25. Arena costs one more mana and is less valuable for that reason, since at the 3-spot it's outclassed. Bob gets around alot of effects that prevent you from drawing cards, Narset, notion thief etc. This means that from about Turn 3 or 4 Night's Whisper will generally be more valuable than a Bob cast on the same turn. . Angrath, the Flame-Chained makes each opponent discard a card and lose two life, so thats at least scalable in EDH. What happens if I have a split card with 2 identifiable spells? You lose life equal to its mana value. How likely is Yusri to get me an omniscience effect, if I have Krark's Thumb out? Its so good, in fact, that you cant play it in Modern or Legacy anymore because its been banned in both formats. I support WotC's goal of shaping Modern in favor of diversity. Trespassers Curse doesnt look like much, but you get to drain those pesky token players. It also kind of stops those infinite blink combos. There were lots of cards to choose from and narrowing down to a list wasnt easy, but I tried to get the most powerful, popular, and competitive ones out there. Doing so for standard means that the money spent might very well be lost money as the prices on the cards fluctuate over that same standard season. Why does everyone say Dark Confident is better than Phyrexian Arena? may, and I mean may, have a place in Modern, but NOT as a direct substitute for Dark Confidant It takes experience to recognize these things, so don't trash on other people for failing to do so. The deck you linked is Extended, which is now gone. Krayhaft it really depends on the deck, you can get some for 500$ which is what you would probably spend in a standard season buying a deck or two (in singles). Seems more of a disadvantage to me. The kicker for Blood Tribute is very doable in vampire decks, or if your commander is a vampire. and this dark side interest everyone. out of boosters. In every zone except the stack, the characteristics of a split card are those of its two halves combined. They create an infinite combo to kill players. JAVASCRIPT IS DISABLED. Set: Ravnica: City of Guilds. Add to Cart. And Melira pod does not cost that much Hell My kiki Pod with most of it foiled out and a Higher price in lands Didnt run that much. Description: At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. @ Krayhaft its a preference thing you can make all the arguments and excuses in the world what it boils down to is If you want it or not and what your willing to do to make it happen. In reading the history of nations, we find that, like individuals, they have their whims and their peculiarities; their seasons of excitement and recklessness, when they care not what they do. The difference with Modern of course is that with "rotation", all I have to do is add a Scavenging Ooze All rights reserved. You lose life equal to its converted mana cost. While these draw outlets are slow in the manner that they take a turn to come online and only draw one card per turn, that's still a ton of card advantage. After the third card the odds that the game has not ended drop significantly, as it becomes increasingly likely that someone has won the game by that point. The prevalence of cheap removal spells like Lightning Bolt and Fatal Push are very good against him. Heavily Played. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! The Princess of Dorne is not idle though, not now. The fact that the card is a Creature adds more value that doesn't make comparisons to non-creatures as cut-and-dry. Browse through cards from Magic's entire history. It was just a little over a grand. It would be abetter option that Dark Confidant. I am in the same boat, incidentally. 2) Dark Confidant has the ability if needed, to throw himself in front of an attacker, or swing in for some damage if the path is clear. , it wouldn't fit the mold as decks that use Dark Confidant Youll draw lots of cards by paying life, and youll draw lots of rituals and cantrips which can result in a storm win in combo decks with cheap cards (0-1 mana value). . You Do Your Best To Hide The Good Parts of Yourself 4. Castle Locthwain allows you to draw cards and lose life by paying black mana, and its a staple for black decks across many formats. When I first started playing magic, I pulled a Ravnica Bob from my tournament pack. Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN. What is the purpose of this D-shaped ring at the base of the tongue on my hiking boots? There are a bunch of these similar decks in EDH that can benefit from it since it helps find new artifacts with the +1 ability and attacks using the -1. Averaging out the mana cost for all of the cards, I found that the average draw would make Bob do 1.22 damage per turn. I play Living End Please enable JavaScript on your browser to best view this site. Card Text: At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. However, Dark Confidant allows you to obtain cards from your library during your upkeep without actually drawing them which may allow you to bypass this restriction. But, yeah, I wonder the same goddam thing every time I see it cast. KingSorin raises another very important point in sort of a sideways manner. Its usually a lifedrain effect followed by a threat that synergizes with enchantments, lifegain effects, and more. And I can always count on long-time friend and confidant, Bruce Samboy, to look over my shoulder with a lceen, investigator's eye; . over Blood Scrivener Again, it's about the mana. This skipping years part is the part that is in contention, no one I know has skipped a standard season, much less multiple, to build from scratch t1 modern decks. Providing a decently aggressive body and early card advantage, Dark Confidant was played everywhere. Just paying six mana to Debt to the Deathless means that you drain two from each opponent and gain six life. At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. Eldritch Moon Spoilers and Set Information, March of the Machine: The Aftermath Spoilers and Set Information, Bloodthirst in MTG: Rules, History, and Best Cards, The 67 Best Recursion Creatures in Magic Ranked. Dark Depths is banned in modern. So the downside is all of 0.22 damage per turn, which I think is probably less than OP envisioned. only triggers if you have no cards in hand, otherwise it would be soooo busted. You have a 2 mana advantage engine, that keeps the life totals even by swinging for 2, that you can bolt to save yourself and that changes how you can curve out. Dark Confidant (Store Championship) (Textless): At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. Yeah, that's the problemthe cheap (CMC-wise) aggro decks like Dark Confidant Do Obosh and Brash Taunter together cause quadruple damage to an opponent? Compare Dark Confidant Yup, this. The decks that want bob are actively trying to make the game go long. That is why G/B/X decks do tend to run 1 in their 75, to bring in the mirror or versus decks where they need more CA. 3) Dark Confidant costs 1 less which means he's in play earlier, and gets you at more cards sooner. Children of Korlis gives you life equivalent to the lifeloss you had when you sacrifice it. Discord Server | in that slot. Well, thats all from me on life loss. about Magic: The Gathering, including card images, mana symbols, and Oracle text, The strategy of chess and the variance of poker, all wrapped up in a fantasy medium. It was overexaggerated, but I was going off of the price differences between standard and modern decks. Because life loss doesnt count as damage, it doesnt count as noncombat damage either. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Yes. Card Name Dark Confidant. EDIT: Also because he doesn't technically draw you cards, he gets around hate bears like Spirit of the Labyrinth. And if all 3 cards all have relatively high mana costs, you can tap to put the Divining Top right on top of your library and only take 1 damage when you draw it (since its mana cost is 1. Do i really want to rape my wallet to get some little guy who's potentially going to damage me considerably? Can get cheaper threw trades and eBay deals. February 8, 10. Played. Dark Confidant Dark Confidant Dark Confidant Dark Confidant Dark Confidant Dark Confidant. God-Pharaohs Statue is a common tutor target for Karn, the Great Creator. Draftsim.com is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Fan Content Policy. As for Night's Whisper, bob is much better than night's whisper most of the time so people would rather run bob. 2023 Magic Find, Inc. All rights reserved. If you're paying mid, you're doing it wrong, price at low cause that's what you are really paying, if you're smart. . For those who gamble, interest may even lead to the occasional, innocent experimentation with sleight-of-hand. @gufymike Responding late! sorts of discussions). I think a more apt comparison would be to that of Curiosity or Keen Sense. All rights reserved. Heavily Played. I don't think that KingSorin is trying to compare Bob and Lili per se, but to say that you expect to get more out of a 3-drop. Dark Confidant. Official blog for Card Kingdom, delivering Magic: The Gathering cards and supplies from Seattle to the world since 1999.